Best Sunmaster Globe For vegging. Cool vs neutral vs Warm

[TheTreeBoundRat]

I want to know Which of these bulbs is the best suited purely for the vegetative state. I know the blue spectrum is surposed to be better than warm for vegging but the blue delux puts out less lumens than the warm delux. Which is more important lumens or spectrum?

 

Sunmaster recommends blue for vegging and warm for allround use but because of the lumen diference I'm still confused as to which one to use. My hydro shop sold me the warm, saying they were better.

 

Heres a couple of links to the globes.

 

http://www.hydroponics.com/hydroshops/usa_.../growlamps.html

 

http://www.venturelighting.com.au/ heaps of info here but doesn't definitively answer my question.

 

Heres some info

 

BRAND MAKE CATEGORY WATTS INITIAL LUMENS PAR WATTS CCT

 

Sunmaster Warm Deluxe MH 1000 110000 441 ~3K

Sunmaster Natural Deluxe MH 1000 110000 416 ~4K

Sunmaster Cool Deluxe MH 1000 80000 340 ~5K

 

Can anyone shed some light?

RR

[everest]

on that info rat, looks like the wam one wins , to be honest i don't think you would notice the difference ...so long as its mh

 

ev